Home/Best-Of/Best villas in Tuscany
Best-Of  ·  Tuscany

The 15 Best Luxury Villas in Tuscany (Ranked by Region)

Fifteen ranked properties across Chianti, Val d’Orcia, and the Maremma coast, with the cook-in-the-kitchen norm spelled out and ten passed-on villas named at the bottom.

This page contains affiliate links. If you book through them we earn a commission, paid by the platform, at no cost to you. We have not adjusted our rankings for the commission rate. Full breakdown on our how-we-make-money page.
Villas ranked15
Considered, passed on10 named
Peak rate range$8,000 to $65,000 / wk
Last updated2026-05

Tuscany is three rental markets in one region. Chianti runs design-led and dense, with shorter drives and stronger restaurant proximity. Val d’Orcia runs estate-style and remote, with the photogenic landscapes and the longest drives to anywhere. The Maremma coast runs pine-shaded and beach-adjacent, with the lowest restaurant density and the best sea swimming. The right villa in the wrong region is the wrong villa.

We started this list with 84 villas. Fifteen made it, five from each region. Ten more are at the bottom in the passed-on block. Prices are peak season (mid-June to early September), 7 nights, before service (typically 10%), Italian government tax (typically €3 to €5 per person per night), staff gratuity (€500 to €1,200 per staff member per week), and chef costs where not included. The cook-in-the-kitchen norm holds in Tuscany: 11 of the 15 villas below include a dinner-five-nights-a-week cook in the rate.

Each entry names the region, bedroom count, sleeps, peak weekly rate, what is and is not included, our verdict, and what we would change. The full Tuscany framework, including the driving-time math (most properties are 25 to 40 minutes from anywhere worth eating), is on the Tuscany destination page.

Section I  ·  Chianti (5 villas)

The shorter-drive region.

Between Florence and Siena. Strong restaurant density. The villas run smaller and more design-led than Val d’Orcia.

No. I

The seven-bedroom Chianti estate, Greve hillside.

Bedrooms: 7. Sleeps: 14. Region: Chianti. Peak rate: $28,000 to $42,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (dinner five nights), gardener, one car. Not included: chef upgrade, wine, second car.

Why it ranks here: the cook is the test, and the cook here is strong. The hillside position above Greve in Chianti puts the property 18 minutes from Panzano and 35 from Siena. Seven king bedrooms, an 18-meter pool, and a kitchen that the cook actually controls (some Tuscany cooks work around the guests, the better ones do not). Outdoor dining is sheltered by the loggia.

What we would change: the wine cellar is well-stocked and overpriced. Bring your own.

Check rates on The Thinking Traveller   Check rates direct

No. II

The five-bedroom Castellina villa, vineyard-edge.

Bedrooms: 5. Sleeps: 10. Region: Chianti. Peak rate: $18,000 to $26,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (four nights), one car. Not included: gardener visible, second car, wine.

Why it ranks here: the small-group Chianti pick. Five king bedrooms across one building, a 14-meter pool, and a vineyard edge that runs to the property line. The cook is the previous owner’s mother-in-law, which is the kind of fact you learn after you book. The food is exactly as good as that implies.

What we would change: add a second cook night. The four-night standard leaves three meals for the group to figure out.

Check rates

No. III

The eight-bedroom Radda estate.

Bedrooms: 8. Sleeps: 16. Region: Chianti. Peak rate: $36,000 to $52,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights), gardener, two cars, daily breakfast. Not included: chef upgrade, third car.

Why it ranks here: the multi-generational pick on the Chianti list. Three buildings on a single property, separate kitchens in two of them, and a configuration that lets two households cohabit without losing sleep. The drive to Radda is 8 minutes. The drive to Siena is 38.

What we would change: the secondary building’s AC is older and louder. Designate it for adults who do not sleep with the AC on.

Check rates

No. IV

The four-bedroom Panzano villa, ridge position.

Bedrooms: 4. Sleeps: 8. Region: Chianti. Peak rate: $14,000 to $20,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (four nights), one car. Not included: gardener visible, wine.

Why it ranks here: the Panzano restaurant proximity matters more than people expect when planning. Officina della Bistecca is a 14-minute drive. The villa itself is competent rather than special, but the cook is strong and the kitchen is configured for actual cooking, not display.

What we would change: the pool faces afternoon sun without shade. Add umbrellas. The owner has said no twice. The shade is the only complaint.

Check rates

No. V

The six-bedroom San Casciano villa.

Bedrooms: 6. Sleeps: 12. Region: Chianti. Peak rate: $20,000 to $30,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights), gardener, one car. Not included: second car, chef upgrade.

Why it ranks here: the closest Chianti pick to Florence. The drive into the city is 32 minutes off-peak. Six king bedrooms, a 14-meter pool, and a vegetable garden the cook actually uses. Right for a group that wants villa days and Florence dinners.

What we would change: the road noise from the lower vineyard road carries on Sundays. Quieter from the back of the property.

Check rates

Section II  ·  Val d’Orcia (5 villas)

The estate-style region.

South of Siena. Longer drives, larger properties, the postcard landscape. The villas run estate-scale and the cook norm is universal.

No. VI

The 12-bedroom Pienza estate.

Bedrooms: 12. Sleeps: 24. Region: Val d’Orcia. Peak rate: $48,000 to $65,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights, two staff), gardener, three cars, daily breakfast service. Not included: chef upgrade, fourth car, wine.

Why it ranks here: the largest property on the list and the rare 24-person villa where the configuration actually works. Three buildings, separate kitchens in two of them, two pools. The drive to Pienza is 12 minutes. The drive to Montalcino is 28. For a 24-person family reunion or milestone birthday, this is the right answer.

What we would change: the chef-night minimum is five nights, with the cook’s strong-but-narrow repertoire across all five. Hire a guest chef for one or two nights to break the pattern.

Check rates

No. VII

The eight-bedroom Montalcino estate.

Bedrooms: 8. Sleeps: 16. Region: Val d’Orcia. Peak rate: $32,000 to $46,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights), gardener, two cars. Not included: chef upgrade, third car, wine.

Why it ranks here: Brunello country. The property is on the south flank of Montalcino with a long drive to anywhere (Pienza is 38 minutes, Siena 50). The 14-meter pool, the cook, and the eight king bedrooms hold up at the price.

What we would change: the Wi-Fi runs slow. Hire the satellite backup.

Check rates

No. VIII

The six-bedroom San Quirico farmhouse.

Bedrooms: 6. Sleeps: 12. Region: Val d’Orcia. Peak rate: $22,000 to $32,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (four nights), gardener, one car. Not included: second car, wine.

Why it ranks here: the postcard-landscape pick. The property sits on the ridge above San Quirico with sightlines into the cypress-lined hills below. Six king bedrooms, a 12-meter pool, and a cook whose pasta is reason enough to skip the restaurants two of four cook nights.

What we would change: the lower-bedroom window faces the gravel drive. Designate that room for someone who sleeps deep.

Check rates

No. IX

The five-bedroom Pienza casale.

Bedrooms: 5. Sleeps: 10. Region: Val d’Orcia. Peak rate: $18,000 to $26,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights), one car. Not included: second car, wine, gardener visible.

Why it ranks here: the small-group Val d’Orcia pick. Five king bedrooms, a 10-meter pool, and the strongest cook on the list at this price point. The drive to Pienza is 10 minutes. The drive to Montepulciano is 22.

What we would change: add the gardener-visible upgrade. The grounds look better than they would without it.

Check rates

No. X

The seven-bedroom Castiglione del Bosco-adjacent villa.

Bedrooms: 7. Sleeps: 14. Region: Val d’Orcia. Peak rate: $28,000 to $40,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights), gardener, two cars, golf access at the adjacent estate. Not included: chef upgrade, third car, wine, spa.

Why it ranks here: the golf-access pick, with reciprocal arrangements at the adjacent Rosewood estate course. Seven king bedrooms, a 16-meter pool, and a separate guest house that takes pressure off the main building. The drive to Montalcino is 22 minutes.

What we would change: the golf access is described as “subject to availability” in the contract. Confirm in writing before booking. The pro shop will not call.

Check rates

Section III  ·  Maremma Coast (5 villas)

The coastal region.

Southwest Tuscany. Pine-shaded, beach-adjacent, lower restaurant density than Chianti. The villas run flatter and the pools matter more.

No. XI

The six-bedroom Castiglione della Pescaia villa.

Bedrooms: 6. Sleeps: 12. Region: Maremma. Peak rate: $24,000 to $36,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (four nights), gardener, two cars, beach club walk-in at Roccamare. Not included: chef upgrade, third car, wine.

Why it ranks here: the Maremma pick for a group that wants villa days and beach afternoons. Six king bedrooms, a 14-meter pool, and pine shade over the outdoor dining. The Roccamare beach access is the trade-off you get for the Maremma drive times.

What we would change: the cook is competent rather than special. Hire a chef for one night to demonstrate the gap.

Check rates

No. XII

The four-bedroom Punta Ala villa.

Bedrooms: 4. Sleeps: 8. Region: Maremma. Peak rate: $12,000 to $18,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (three nights), one car. Not included: beach service, chef upgrade.

Why it ranks here: the small-group Maremma pick. Four king bedrooms, a 10-meter pool, and a 7-minute walk to the Punta Ala marina restaurants. The pine shade is real. The Wi-Fi is reliable, which is not a given on this coast.

What we would change: add cook nights. The three-night standard is the wrong default for a coast where the restaurant density is light.

Check rates

No. XIII

The five-bedroom Argentario villa.

Bedrooms: 5. Sleeps: 10. Region: Maremma. Peak rate: $18,000 to $26,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (four nights), one car, boat slip. Not included: boat itself, second car, chef upgrade.

Why it ranks here: the Argentario peninsula pick. Five king bedrooms, a 12-meter pool, and a boat slip at the nearby marina that turns the trip into a sea-day rotation. The drive to Porto Ercole is 14 minutes.

What we would change: the slip-only inclusion is misleading. The boat charter is the actual cost, and the marina’s preferred charters are 20 to 30% above the open-water market. Book the boat independently.

Check rates

No. XIV

The seven-bedroom Capalbio estate.

Bedrooms: 7. Sleeps: 14. Region: Maremma. Peak rate: $26,000 to $38,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (five nights), gardener, two cars, daily breakfast. Not included: beach service (drive is 14 minutes), chef upgrade, wine.

Why it ranks here: the Capalbio quiet trade-off. The property sits inland on a working farm, with pine and oak shade, a 16-meter pool, and seven king bedrooms across the main building. The drive to the beach is 14 minutes. The drive to Rome FCO is 90 if you are landing there.

What we would change: the working-farm description means roosters at 5:30am. Designate the south bedrooms for early risers.

Check rates

No. XV

The three-bedroom Cala di Forno villa.

Bedrooms: 3. Sleeps: 6. Region: Maremma. Peak rate: $8,000 to $13,000 / week. Included: housekeeper, cook (two nights), one car. Not included: beach service, chef upgrade.

Why it ranks here: the smallest property on the list and the only one under $10,000 in peak. Three king bedrooms, an 8-meter pool, and a position close enough to the protected coast that the beach walk is a beach walk. Right for two couples or a small family of six who want a Maremma week without the estate price.

What we would change: the kitchen runs small. The cook handles it. A guest chef would not.

Check rates

Section IV  ·  The Cook Norm

How the included cook works in Tuscany.

The cook-in-the-kitchen norm is real, unlike in Mykonos. Eleven of the 15 villas on this list include a cook (typically four or five dinners per week) in the headline rate. The cook is usually a local woman in her 50s or 60s who has worked the property for years. The food is Tuscan, the repertoire is narrow, the execution is high.

The cook covers dinner. Lunch is usually a panzanella, a pasta, and a salad on the terrace. Breakfast is set up before the cook arrives. The grocery shop is done by the housekeeper, against a list the guest provides. The cook is not a chef, will not improvise around dietary requests outside the norms (gluten-free yes, raw vegan no), and does not serve. Set the table yourself.

The chef upgrade replaces or supplements the cook for higher-end menus. Costs run €500 to €900 per night in Chianti and Val d’Orcia, slightly higher on the Maremma coast. The right move on most weeks is to keep the cook for four nights and hire a chef for one or two. The contrast is the point.

Section V  ·  The Disclosure

Ten villas we considered and passed on.

Properties listed on The Thinking Traveller, Le Collectionist, Plum Guide, or direct from the management companies in the same price ranges as the ranked fifteen.

  • The Lucca eight-bedroom estate listed at $38,000 / week. The Lucca position adds 90 minutes of drive time to everywhere worth eating south of the city. Right for a Lucca trip. Wrong for a Tuscany trip.
  • The Greve six-bedroom listed at $24,000 / week. Cook is the management company’s cousin. Food is fine. The kitchen is the cook’s, not the guest’s, which is the wrong default in Chianti.
  • The Cortona seven-bedroom listed at $30,000 / week. Photography on the major platforms is five years older than current condition. Pool tiling is failing.
  • The Montepulciano five-bedroom listed at $20,000 / week. Wi-Fi runs 8 to 15 Mbps. Manager will not commit to backup. Three readers have complained.
  • The Pisa-adjacent six-bedroom listed at $26,000 / week. Airport noise from PSA runs to 11pm in summer. Photography on the platform pretends it is rural.
  • The Forte dei Marmi five-bedroom listed at $22,000 / week. Forte dei Marmi villa pricing is built around the August Italian market. Off-week pricing is the headline. On-week pricing doubles.
  • The Castiglione del Lago four-bedroom listed at $14,000 / week. The villa is in Umbria. The listing places it in Tuscany. The 90-minute drive to Siena is the relevant fact.
  • The San Gimignano seven-bedroom listed at $32,000 / week. Tour-bus traffic from May through September makes the morning drive into town a 35-minute exercise. The villa is fine. The location is not.
  • The Pienza five-bedroom listed at $20,000 / week. Different property from our number nine. Pattern of deposit-return disputes documented in four reader emails across 2024 and 2025.
  • The Maremma six-bedroom listed at $24,000 / week. Pool not gated, listing claims family-friendly. The drop to the lower terrace is sharp.
Section VI  ·  How We Built This List

The methodology.

Built from on-site stays (we have stayed in 9 of the 15), site visits without stay (5 properties), management interviews (all 15, between October 2025 and April 2026), and verified guest reports from readers who booked through us in 2024 and 2025. Properties scored against the 40-point checklist with regional weighting (cook quality is weighted higher in Tuscany than in Mykonos). The full checklist is on the methodology page.

Refreshed quarterly. Last refresh: May 2026. Next refresh: August 2026. If you have stayed in any villa on this list, ranked or passed-on, and your experience differs from our description, write to editorial. We update or remove on verification.

The For Kings Network

The rest of the Tuscany trip.

The hotel for the short version. The trattorias and the one Michelin-three in the region worth the drive. The bars where the wine list is not just the local consortium.

Hotels For Kings: Tuscany Restaurants For Kings: Tuscany Bars For Kings: Tuscany

Where to next.

PillarAll best-of villa guides, sorted by destination and occasion. DestinationThe full Tuscany guide with regions, cost data, and the cook norm. SiblingThe 12 best villas in Mykonos, ranked. SiblingThe 10 best villas in St Barts, ranked. PlatformThe Plum Guide review. How-ToThe buyer’s guide to booking a luxury villa. CompareTuscany vs Provence for a villa week. NetworkRestaurants For Kings: Tuscany.